Skip to content
RoofElm

Methodology

How we research the pages, and the formula and assumptions behind every calculator on the site.

Last updated

What the pages are built from

Every fact on RoofElm comes from a source we opened. We go to the official source first: state energy offices, state housing and community agencies, departments of revenue and comptrollers, state licensing boards, legislature and statute sites, the U.S. Department of Energy, the IRS, ENERGY STAR, and manufacturers’ specifications. Each page lists its sources and the date we checked them. The rules we follow are on the editorial policy page.

When we cannot confirm a figure, the page describes the thing without the number. We print no price tables for jobs. What a job costs depends on the size and shape of your roof, your region, the materials and the month, so the project pages explain what drives the cost and how to read a bid.

State pages

There is one page for each of the 50 states and Washington, DC, listed on state help. We research them the same way every time:

  1. We read the state’s own pages for the weatherization program, the federal home energy rebates (HOMES and HEAR), the property tax treatment of rooftop solar, and contractor licensing.
  2. We read the statute or the licensing board’s page for the roofer rule, including any dollar threshold above which a license is required.
  3. We record the answer in five fixed facts: weatherization, home energy rebates, solar property tax, roofer license and climate zones.
  4. We date the check and link the sources.

Each page gives the state one of three roofer-license statuses, which also color the map on the state help page:

  • State license. The state itself requires a license to do roofing work, or a roofing-specific license. The page names the board.
  • Registration. The state does not license roofers but requires roofers or home improvement contractors to register or hold a state certificate.
  • Local only. The state has no license or registration for roofing. Cities, counties and the building code decide.

Home energy rebate status changes often. The page says “open”, “planned, not open” or “not found” and gives the date we read it. Program launch dates differ by state, so check the state’s own status page before you plan around a rebate.

Projects, guides and punch lists

Project pages and guides explain the job, how it is measured, what drives its cost, the order of work, what to ask before you sign, when it is a do-it-yourself job and when it is not, and where permits come in. Where a rule differs by state, the page says so and sends you to state help.

Punch lists are seasonal checklists. Where the weather changes the task, the list separates cold, hot-humid and dry West regions. They are general guidance for a typical house, not an inspection of yours.

The rule changes page logs each change to a law or program with its date and official source.

Calculators

The calculators are on Measure it. They show an estimate from the numbers you enter, not an offer, a bid or a price. Each one states its assumptions next to the result.

Roof squares and shingle bundles. A roofing square is 100 square feet of roof. The tool adds the eave overhang to each side of the house footprint, multiplies by a pitch factor, and divides by 100. For a roof that rises R inches for every 12 inches of run, the pitch factor is the square root of 1 plus (R divided by 12) squared; a 6-in-12 roof gives about 1.118. A waste allowance (10% by default) is added, and bundles are the squares with waste times the bundles per square you choose (3 for most asphalt shingles), rounded up to whole bundles. It treats the roof as simple planes. It does not cover dormers, a second wing, tear-off, underlayment, flashing or labor.

Attic insulation gap. Your R-value is the depth of insulation you have times its R per inch. The target is the ENERGY STAR retrofit figure for an uninsulated attic in your climate zone (R-30 in zone 1, R-49 in zones 2 and 3, R-60 in the colder zones). ENERGY STAR’s table, headed “Add Insulation to Attic,” also gives a lower figure for an attic that already has 3 to 4 inches, and the tool shows both. The gap is the target minus what you have, never less than zero, and the inches to add are the gap divided by the R per inch of the new insulation. R per inch values are typical, not exact: use the label on the product. The tool does not check air leaks, ventilation or moisture, which matter as much as the number.

Rooftop solar payback. First-year output is system size in kilowatts times the yearly kilowatt-hours per kilowatt you enter. Each year’s saving is output times the value of a kilowatt-hour, with the yearly loss of panel output (0.5% by default) and the yearly rise in value (0% by default) you set. Payback is the year the running total reaches the price after the incentive you enter, searched up to 40 years. The tool leaves out the federal residential clean energy credit (25D), which does not apply to property placed in service after December 31, 2025. It adds no financing cost, battery, inverter replacement or roof work, and it counts a state or utility incentive only if you enter it. Whether exported power is credited at the retail rate depends on your utility, so enter the value you expect.

Improvement cost and value. The tool does not use a published table of cost recouped. You enter the project cost, the value a local agent or appraiser says it adds at sale, the yearly savings and the years you will stay. It shows the share of the cost the added value covers, the savings you collect while you stay, and the cost left after both. A negative result is a net gain. Your house, your market and the quality of the work decide the real numbers, and an improvement can be worth making for comfort or repair reasons that have nothing to do with resale.

Yard, concrete and fence materials. Volume in cubic feet is length times width times depth, with depth in inches divided by 12. Cubic yards are cubic feet divided by 27, and the waste allowance (5% to 10% by material, editable) is added for the amount to order. For concrete, an 80 lb bag of mix yields about 0.6 cubic feet, per the manufacturer’s data sheet. For gravel the tool uses a rough 1.4 tons per cubic yard; your supplier’s figure wins. For a straight fence run, sections are the run length divided by the post spacing, rounded up, and posts are sections plus one. Gates, corners, slopes and settling change real orders, so the result is a starting number for a supplier, who should confirm it.

What we do not do

We do not rank contractors, products or companies. If a page ever ranks things, it says the method. We do not claim to have tested or installed anything. Read the disclaimer for the limits of the information here, and use the contact page if you think a formula or a source is wrong.