Skip to content
RoofElm

Roof

Roof replacement, measured before anyone bids

What a full replacement includes, how roofers size it, and what a bid has to say before you sign it.

By RoofElm Editorial Team Updated 7 min read

One roofing square
100 square feet
Bundles per square
3 for most shingles
Layers allowed
2 at most, 1 is better
Attic vent area
1 sq ft per 150 floor
Illustration: a house roof elevation with the ridge, slope, flashing and vents labeled
The layers of a replacement, from the deck up.

In short

A replacement means tearing off the old roof down to the deck, fixing the deck, then installing underlayment, flashing, new shingles and ventilation. Roofers measure in squares of 100 square feet, and most asphalt shingles come three bundles to the square. A fair bid names every layer it will install, says who pulls the permit, and says what happens if rotted decking turns up. If you are not sure the roof needs replacing at all, start with repair or replace.

What a full replacement includes

A replacement is not new shingles laid over old ones. The crew strips every existing layer down to the roof deck, which is the plywood or boards the shingles are nailed to. That is the moment a roofer can see the deck, and it is why the contract should say what happens when some of it is rotten.

  • Deck repair: soft or rotted sheathing cut out and replaced, priced per sheet or per square foot.
  • Underlayment: the water-shedding layer under the shingles, plus an ice-and-water membrane in cold climates.
  • Flashing: the metal at chimneys, walls, valleys and vents, where most leaks start.
  • Shingles and ridge cap: the visible surface, with the brand and product line written in the bid.
  • Ventilation: intake at the eaves and exhaust at the ridge, so the attic can breathe.
  • Cleanup: magnetic nail sweep of the yard and driveway, and haul-away of the old roof.

A replacement is also the cheapest time to fix the attic below it. If the attic is under-insulated or leaks air, read attic insulation and air sealing before the old roof comes off.

Squares, bundles and waste

Roofers price in squares. One square is 10 feet by 10 feet, or 100 square feet of roof surface, and the surface is bigger than the footprint of the house because of the slope. Divide the total roof area by 100 to get squares. Most standard asphalt shingles, 3-tab and architectural, come three bundles to a square, though some specialty lines need four or five.

Example: a 2,400 square foot roof surface
StepMathResult
Roof area in squares2,400 ÷ 10024 squares
Bundles at 3 per square24 × 372 bundles
With about 15% extra for cuts and waste72 × 1.1583 bundles

The extra is a rule of thumb used in one worked example from This Old House, and a complex roof with many hips and valleys wastes more. Use the roof squares calculator to turn a footprint and a pitch into squares, then compare the number with the one in each bid. A bid that is far off from your number is worth a question, not a signature.

Tear-off or roof-over

Some bids offer to put a second layer of shingles over the first to save the tear-off cost. The model building code the states build on, the International Residential Code, section R908, says a roof replacement removes the existing layers down to the deck, and a new covering cannot go over a roof that already has two or more layers. Cities adopt their own versions, so the building office has the last word.

Ventilation and the attic

The code asks for 1 square foot of net free vent area for every 150 square feet of attic floor. It allows 1 square foot per 300 when the vents are balanced, with about half the area high at the ridge and the rest low at the eaves, plus other conditions. Net free area is the real open area of a vent, not the size printed on the package. Ask the roofer to show the arithmetic for your attic, and make sure the new vents do not leave the old ones blocked.

What to ask before you sign

  1. Ask each roofer for the permit plan: who applies, who pays, and who is at the inspection. See permits and inspections.
  2. Get the shingle brand, product line and color, the underlayment, the flashing metal and the vent type written into each bid.
  3. Ask what the deck repair price is per sheet, and who decides when a board is bad.
  4. Ask for a certificate of insurance sent by the insurer, and for the roofer's written workmanship warranty, with the years it lasts.
  5. Compare bids line by line with the estimate reading guide, and be wary of a bid that is much lower than the rest or that pushes you to sign today.
  6. After the job, get a lien waiver with the final payment. Contracts, warranties and lien waivers explains why.

After a hail or wind storm, door-knockers appear. How to spot a roofing scam covers the offers to waive your deductible and the contracts that sign your insurance claim over. Whether your state licenses roofers is on the state help pages.

What drives the price

A roof price is the sum of area, pitch, complexity, material, deck repair, access and local labor, and it moves with the season and after storms. We do not publish dollar ranges, because they are out of date by the time you read them. Use the squares number to ask each bidder for a price per square, and ask what is and is not in it.

Roof shape

Steep pitches, many valleys, dormers and chimneys add labor and waste.

Material

Architectural shingles, metal, tile and slate each have different price and installation needs.

Surprises

Rotted decking, a second layer and failed flashing are found only after tear-off. The bid should price them in advance.

The fairest way to compare is to ask every roofer to bid the same scope: the same squares number, the same shingle line, the same underlayment and the same disposal. Then the only differences left are price, warranty and the crew. Season matters too. Roofers are busiest after storm season and in early fall, so a bid in November for work in January may be easier to schedule than one in a hurry.

Common questions

How long does a roof replacement take?

A typical house is often torn off and re-roofed in one to three days, depending on size, weather and crew. Ask the roofer for the schedule in writing and what happens if rain delays it.

Do I need a permit to replace a roof?

Most cities and counties require one, and the roofer or you must apply. Call your building office to confirm. Texas, for example, has no state roofing rules, so the city decides.

Can I put new shingles over old ones?

Sometimes, but the model code does not allow it over two or more layers, and it hides deck problems. Check with your building office and ask for the shingle maker's warranty terms in writing.

Should I replace my insulation when I replace the roof?

It is the best time to look. The attic is easiest to reach and air-seal while the roof is being redone, so ask for an attic check before you sign.

Sources

Facts checked on November 19, 2026. Building codes are adopted city by city and change on a three-year cycle: confirm your local rule with the building office.