Roof
Roofing materials: what to compare before you pick
Asphalt, metal, tile, slate and shake differ in weight, installation and upkeep. Here is how to read the ratings and ask the right questions.
By RoofElm Editorial Team Updated 7 min read
- Asphalt shingle life
- Two to three decades
- Top wind class, D3161
- Class F, 110 mph
- Top wind class, D7158
- Class H, 150 mph
- Top fire class
- Class A
In short
Asphalt shingles are the usual starting point, and Owens Corning says a properly installed shingle roof can protect a house for two to three decades. Metal, tile, slate and shake are real alternatives, but each one changes the weight on the roof frame, the flashing details and who can install it. Compare materials by ratings printed on the package, the written warranty and the installer's experience with that material, not by a sales pitch. If you have not decided whether to replace at all, start with repair or replace.
The main roofing materials
A roofing material is only the top layer. Under it are the deck, the underlayment and the flashing, which do most of the water-shedding work. The choice mostly decides how the roof looks, how much it weighs, how it handles wind, hail and fire, and who is qualified to install it.
Asphalt shingles
The usual starting point. Sold in bundles, installed by most roofers, and available as 3-tab or architectural shingles.
Metal
Standing-seam panels or shingle-style metal. Installation depends on the panel system and the fasteners, so the crew's experience with that exact product matters.
Clay and concrete tile
Heavier than shingles. Ask for a check of the roof frame before you commit.
Slate
Natural stone and heavy. A specialty trade, so ask how many slate roofs the crew has installed.
Wood shake and synthetic
Wood shake brings fire-rating and local-code questions. Synthetic products imitate slate or shake, and each maker's warranty and ratings are its own.
Start with the hazard, not the look. List what your roof actually faces: high wind, hail, wildfire embers, heavy snow or a mild climate with none of those. Then match the hazard to a rating you can read on a package, and check the local rules, because some fire districts and associations limit what you can install.
We do not publish a lifespan or a price for each of these. Lifespan claims come from sales pages, and prices go stale. Ask the manufacturer for the written warranty and the installation guide, and read what the warranty excludes.
Asphalt shingles: what the label tells you
Shingles carry test ratings that you can compare, and the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) publishes what the standards mean. A rating describes the shingle as made and tested in a lab. ARMA also warns that lab tests do not fully replicate real roofs, and that installation by the maker's instructions matters as much as the label.
| Standard | What it tests | Top class |
|---|---|---|
| ASTM D3161 | Wind, by fan | Class F, 110 mph |
| ASTM D7158 | Wind, by uplift force | Class H, 150 mph |
| ASTM E108 or UL 790 | Fire from outside the house | Class A, of A, B and C |
| UL 2218 | Impact, steel balls dropped | Class 4, of four classes |
Owens Corning lists the full wind ladder: D3161 Class A at 60 mph, Class D at 90 mph and Class F at 110 mph, and D7158 Class D at 90 mph, Class G at 120 mph and Class H at 150 mph. It says most shingles carry D3161 Class F and D7158 Class H, that warranted wind coverage varies by product, and that local building codes decide the level your roof needs. Look for the classification on the wrapper, then ask your building office what it requires. For impact, ARMA says UL 2218 drops steel balls from 12 to 20 feet onto the shingle, and FM 4473 uses launched ice balls. Both have four classes, and Class 4 is the highest.
Bundles, squares and a worked example
Shingles are sold in bundles and priced in squares. One square covers 100 square feet, and most shingles come three bundles to the square, though some specialty lines need four or five. Take a roof surface of 2,400 square feet. That is 24 squares, and the bundles depend on the line you pick.
| Bundles per square | Coverage per bundle | Bundles for 24 squares |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 100 ÷ 3 = 33.3 sq ft | 24 × 3 = 72 |
| 4 | 100 ÷ 4 = 25 sq ft | 24 × 4 = 96 |
| 5 | 100 ÷ 5 = 20 sq ft | 24 × 5 = 120 |
The package states the coverage of the product you buy, so use its number, not these. Add an allowance for cuts and waste, which roof replacement explains, and check your own area with the roof squares calculator. Other materials are sold by other units, so ask the supplier for the unit and the count.
What drives the price
A material's sticker price is a small part of the bid. The labor, the underlayment, the flashing, the deck repair and the disposal ride along with it, and they change with the material.
- Weight and framing: a heavy covering may need the roof frame checked or reinforced before it goes on.
- Installer skill: metal, tile and slate need crews who know the material, and the bid reflects that.
- Roof shape: valleys, dormers, hips and chimneys add cuts and flashing on any material.
- Fastening and flashing: each material has its own fasteners and flashing details, and the wrong ones can cost you the warranty.
- Local rules: some towns, fire districts and homeowner associations limit which materials you can use.
To compare fairly, ask each roofer for the same scope in the same words, as the estimate reading guide describes, and ask for a price per square for each material you are weighing.
Questions to ask before you choose
- Ask the roofer how many roofs of this material the crew has installed in the last year, and ask to see the maker's installation guide.
- Get the product line, color and underlayment written into the bid, with the wind and impact classes printed on the package.
- Ask what the material warranty covers, for how many years, and who is the contact if a claim comes up, the maker or the roofer.
- Ask whether the roof frame needs a check for weight, and who signs off on it.
- Ask your building office about permits and any limit on materials, and see permits and inspections.
- Ask your insurer whether the material or its impact rating changes anything on your policy, and read roof age and homeowners insurance for how age enters the picture.
DIY or hire out
A full roof is not a first DIY project. Falls from roofs and ladders are a real danger, and every material has installation rules that affect the warranty. Buying the material yourself and hiring labor can leave nobody responsible for a leak. If you do any roof work, keep to ladders on firm ground, stay clear of power lines and stay off a wet or frosty roof.
If a storm forced the choice, read how to spot a roofing scam before you sign. Solar plans change the order of work, which solar panels and roof age explains.
Common questions
Which roofing material lasts the longest?
RoofElm does not rank materials by lifespan, because the claims come from sellers and depend on installation and climate. Owens Corning says properly installed asphalt shingles protect a house for two to three decades. For other materials, ask the maker for the written warranty and read the exclusions.
What does Class F or Class H mean on a shingle?
They are the top classes of two wind tests. Class F is the top class of ASTM D3161, which uses a fan, at 110 mph. Class H is the top class of ASTM D7158, which measures uplift force, at 150 mph.
Do I need a permit when I change roofing material?
Usually yes, and some places limit materials by fire zone or by homeowner association rules. Call your building office before you order.
Can a heavier material go on my existing roof?
Only after someone checks that the roof frame can carry it. Ask the roofer who does the check and whether the bid includes reinforcing.
Sources
- Owens Corning: Understanding asphalt shingle wind resistance
- Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association: Asphalt shingle product and test standards
- Owens Corning: When to replace your roof
- GAF: What is a roofing square?
- GAF: How many bundles of shingles are in a square?
Facts checked on November 19, 2026. Shingle ratings describe the product as tested, not your roof. Building codes are adopted city by city: confirm your local rule with the building office.
Next on the job
-
Project
Roof replacement
Tear-off, squares, ventilation and the questions to ask before you sign a bid.
-
Project
Roof repair or replace
Signs for each, two rules of thumb worked out in squares, and what to ask roofers.
-
Guide
Read a contractor estimate
Scope, named materials, allowances and exclusions: what every home improvement bid should say.